"Hamas can be defeated in a few weeks"

Major General (Res.) Yiftach Ron-Tal, former Israeli Ground Forces Commander, is dropping some hard truths. He’s got a plan to wrap up this mess with Hamas, and he’s not blowing smoke. “Hamas can be defeated in a few weeks,” he says, pushing for a clear military timetable to slam the door shut on this war’s final act. No dragging it out, no half-measures—get it done.

Ron-Tal’s not here for a prolonged slugfest with the scumcrumpets. He’s convinced that stretching this conflict out is like shooting Israel’s strategic goals in the foot. A defined endgame isn’t just nice to have; it’s make-or-break for the nation’s future. 

This man has been in the room with Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu, having quick chats during the war’s peak, laying out his security takes. But was Bibi really listening? 

Ron-Tal’s not so sure. The Gaza outcome left him shaking his head at Israel’s security clusterfracks in the past.

 
“We are in the midst of a difficult and prolonged campaign for the very existence of the Jewish people in their land,” he says, and he’s not just talking about October 7, 2023. That was the spark, not the fire. 

The real problem? Years of missteps by the army and the state. Let’s rewind to the first big blunder: pulling out of South Lebanon.

Back in 2000, former PM Ehud Barak decided to ditch South Lebanon, waving goodbye to a key security buffer for northern Israel. “The first mistake was the decision by Ehud Barak to evacuate South Lebanon,” Ron-Tal explains. “He gave up the territory that served as a security buffer for northern Israel. He did not do this as part of a comprehensive agreement but unilaterally and for nothing.” No deal, no backup, just a shrug and a retreat. In the Middle East, that’s like walking into a lion’s den wearing a meat suit. 

“In the Middle East, you don’t do business with the weak,” he states. “You test your ability to forge alliances and uphold them.” Israel bailed on the South Lebanese Army (SLA), leaving allies high and dry. Families split, Druze and Christians stuck in Israel, cut off from Lebanon—rough stuff.

Ron-Tal saw the fallout up close. As head of the Israel Electric Corporation, he gave jobs to SLA folks, but many were left twisting in the wind. That Lebanon exit? It let Hezbollah flex its muscles, build bunkers, and gear up for trouble. “The evacuation of South Lebanon allowed Hezbollah to build itself, strengthen its sources, and establish infrastructure to harm Israel,” he says. Cue the Second Lebanon War, when it all blew up in Israel’s face.

Now, let’s talk Gaza. 

Ron-Tal’s tying this mess to the same old security screw-ups. For two decades, Israel banked on “quiet will be met with quiet,” letting Hezbollah and others bulk up without a peep. “Not only did we suffer the greatest failure in Israel's military history under favorable conditions,” he says, “but we also failed to destroy Hezbollah.” 

That strategy? A fantasy that rockets would just rust away. Instead, Hezbollah got four times stronger by October 2023. “This allowed Hezbollah to grow undisturbed and reach October 2023, stronger by about four times in terms of readiness and capabilities compared to 2006,” he notes. And who hit Israel that month? Not Hezbollah—Hamas. “In October 2023, Hamas attacked us, not Hezbollah,” he says, pointing out how threats keep shifting while Israel’s caught napping.

Then there’s the 2005 Gaza disengagement, which Ron-Tal calls a “national and security disgrace.” He was floored watching soldiers forced to evict Jews from legally built settlements. “I couldn’t believe I would have to fight a military that was practically forced to expel Jews from their homes, not in homes that had been broken into under cover of darkness, but in settlements that were established legally and democratically,” he recalls. 

Israel pulled out like a kid playing peekaboo, thinking nobody’d notice. “We left Gaza like a child closing its eyes, thinking no one would see it,” he says. Result? Hamas turned Gaza into a terror state, building power for 20 years with barely a challenge.

The IDF’s whole vibe also shifted, Ron-Tal says. Once built to crush enemies on multiple fronts, it morphed into a conflict-management machine, all about deterrence, not action. “From a perception of victory and an army built to defeat on multiple fronts, we built an army focused on managing conflicts and deterrence, an army that does everything except harming the capabilities that developed right before our eyes,” he explains. That’s on the political bosses, who leaned hard into “quiet will be met with quiet.” “The responsibility for this concept also lies with the military leadership,” he says, “But mainly with the political leadership.” 

Problem is, the politicos keep dodging the blame, like they did post-Yom Kippur War; like they do all over the Western world.

So, who needs step up? 

Ron-Tal’s clear: the military brass who botched this should quit. “The appointed echelon that is directly responsible for this disaster should express its responsibility through its resignation,” he says. The Chief of Staff, Head of Military Intelligence, Southern Command General—they’re out. He thinks the Shin Bet head should follow. For the political crowd? Elections are the only way to rebuild trust. “In a democracy, the way to regain trust is through elections,” he states.

If you enjoy my blog, feel free to toss a virtual coffee my way on Buy Me a Coffee – it’s like a high-five with caffeine! No pressure, it's your call.

What’s next for Gaza? 

Ron-Tal’s calling for a full-court press—crank up the military heat, set up military governance for a bit. “Full recapture of the strip must be accompanied by the establishment of military governance for a limited time,” he says. That would kneecap Hamas and let a new Palestinian leadership rise, one not tied to Hamas or the Palestinian Authority, maybe with help from so called moderate Arab states.

And the hostages? Non-negotiable. “Returning the hostages is the supreme moral and ethical objective of a state that abandoned its citizens,” he says. “I don’t think anyone in Israel doesn’t want the hostages to come back home.” Only way to make that happen? Keep the pressure on, hard and fast.

Ron-Tal’s not just throwing shade—he’s laying out a roadmap. Israel’s got to stop tripping over its own feet, learn from past screwups, and hit the ground running. Time’s ticking.

Tweet