Posts
There is a particular sort of establishment that flatters itself as a sanctuary of conscience. It sells coffee, posts murals, and treats the slaughter of Jews as a branding exercise.
Jerusalem Coffee House in Oakland has now closed its doors, at least for the moment, while its owners prepare for an October federal civil rights trial. The pause is not an act of reflection. It is the consequence of having spent years turning a public café into a checkpoint for Jewish identity.
The Palestinian-owned shop remained shut on Wednesday after announcing it would stop operating after August 23. Three lawsuits allege that it discriminated against Jewish customers, among them a father and his five-year-old son. One of those cases is a Justice Department action under Title II of the Civil Rights Act of 1964, scheduled for trial on October 26.
A federal judge has already refused to throw it out. The complaint is not complicated. Fathi Abdulrahim Harara and his staff allegedly refused service to Jewish customers wearing Star of David caps and then followed them into the street with insults and threats.
That is the oldest prejudice in the Western world, rehearsed over an espresso machine.The café prefers another story. In an August statement on Substack it blamed its legal troubles on a campaign to silence its politics.
"These lawsuits represent the ongoing efforts of Zionist organizations [read: Jewish organizations] and the federal government to use the courts as a tool to repress free speech and public political commitments to Palestine," it said.
Note the sleight of hand. The Star of David becomes “Zionist harassment.” A father and a child become instruments of the federal government. Israel, the Jewish state that exists because Jews learned what happens when they are left without one, is recast as the aggressor.
The massacre of October 7, in which Palestinian terrorists murdered more than 1,200 people and dragged children and Americans into Gaza as hostages, is treated as background noise. The Jewish customer who declines to disavow his people is the problem.
Elizabeth Barcohana, the California Republican Party Jewish engagement chair and an attorney, put the inversion with the precision it deserves. "It is ironic that after freely expressing support for terrorism with these beverage names, the café owners appear to now be using the First Amendment as a defense for ejecting two Jewish customers who wore hats with Stars of David on them, in one case calling it a 'violent' hat," she said. "By their own standard, if a hat can be violent, so can an iced tea. The First Amendment protects speech on hats; it does NOT protect businesses open to the public to discriminate against its customers because they're Jews while chasing them in the street shouting 'Jew' at them."
On the one-year anniversary of October 7th, a Palestinian terrorist attack against innocent civilians that killed over 1,200 people and took hundreds of hostages including children and Americans, Jerusalem Coffee Shop in Oakland unveiled a new menu celebrating terrorism. Beverage items named 'Iced in Tea Fada' celebrate Intifada (an Arabic call to violence signifying resistance by any means necessary, including terrorism) and 'Sweet Sinwar' honoring the principal architect behind the attack," she added.
The cowardly shop owner denied that “Sweet Sinwar” referred to the Hamas leader who planned the slaughter, and claimed the October 7 menu launch merely marked its own anniversary.
One may believe that if one is determined to. The rest of us can read. Intifada is not a flavor. Sinwar was not a pastry chef. Israel’s war in Gaza is the war that any nation would fight after its civilians were hunted in their homes. To name a drink after the architect of that hunt, on the anniversary of the hunt, and then to call a Jewish child’s father a “violent” presence for wearing the symbol of his people, is not speech. It is a confession.
Barcohana hopes the shutdown lasts. "The owners have temporarily closed the coffee shop while they defend this discrimination lawsuit against them," she said. "Hopefully it remains permanently closed."
The Anti-Defamation League and Benesch sued on behalf of Michael Radice, who says he was refused service and subjected to anti-Semitic slurs. The Louis D. Brandeis Center filed a state case for Jonathan Hirsch, ejected with his young son after Harara confronted him over the Star of David. The Justice Department filed in June 2025. When it did, Assistant Attorney General Harmeet K. Dhillon of the Civil Rights Division stated the law without the usual throat-clearing. "It is illegal, intolerable and reprehensible for any American business open to the public to refuse to serve Jewish customers," she said. "Through our vigorous enforcement of Title II of the Civil Rights Act and other laws prohibiting race and religious discrimination, the Justice Department is committed to combatting anti-Semitism and discrimination and protecting the civil rights of all Americans."
That is the point the café and its chorus refuse to grasp. You may despise Israel. You may chant for Palestine until the cups rattle. You may even, in the moral slum that parts of American progressivism have become, treat Hamas as folklore. What you may not do is open a shop to the public and then decide that Jews, identified by the oldest emblem of their faith and peoplehood, are unfit to sit down.
Thanks for following Brain Flushings. Please take time to check out the sponsors on this page--it's one way to support my work and you don't need to purchase anything to do so. Of course, you can Buy Me A Coffee [but not at the Jerusalem Cafe] at any amount if you want to support me directly. And finally, don't be afraid to subscribe if you enjoy the blog--it's free, and worth the cost.
Zionism is not a hat crime. It is the name for the Jewish refusal to be murdered again and then lectured about it. Oakland has produced a case study in how anti-Semitism now travels. It arrives as solidarity. It names its drinks after killers. It tells a five-year-old that his father must leave. Then it files the paperwork of martyrdom and calls the courts a Zionist plot. Israel remains the only democracy in its neighborhood and the only state that would have been condemned for surviving October 7. The coffee shop is closed. The argument it made about Jews is not.
No comments:
Post a Comment